The arguments

Did the Chili Queens of San Antonio give us chili, and why did they disappear?

Argument heat

For decades, women cooked and sold chili con carne from open-air stands in San Antonio's plazas, beginning on Military Plaza. Many accounts treat them as chili's origin story, while others see a dish with older and wider roots. The city's health department pushed them out, and sources disagree on exactly when.

The Chili Queens were women who set up tables and lanterns in San Antonio's plazas at night and sold chili con carne, tamales and enchiladas. National Geographic places them on Military Plaza in the 1880s, cooking over mesquite fires beside wagons hung with colored lanterns. The Handbook of Texas also names Alamo Plaza and Market Square.

They moved as the city grew. Frank W. Jennings writes that the tables stood on Military Plaza, the city's first market, until City Hall was built there in 1889. After the Municipal Market House went up in Market Square in 1900, the cooks moved west to Haymarket Plaza and Milam Park. Barry Popik's newspaper search finds the phrase "chile queen" in a San Antonio paper in 1891, and National Geographic says a San Antonio Chili Stand helped spread the dish at the 1893 Chicago World's Fair.

Visitors wrote about them. Stephen Crane was unimpressed by the heat of the food. O. Henry, who lived in San Antonio in 1895 and 1896, set a short story among the stands.

Their end is dated several ways. Popik quotes a San Antonio Light report of 12 September 1937 saying the health department had ordered the queens out of Haymarket Square, where the city had already confined them. Jennings says the health department closed the stands for good in the early 1940s over their dishwashing methods. Texas Public Radio says they had been driven from the downtown plazas by the 1930s, after restaurant owners complained and new inspection rules followed.

Whether they invented chili is its own argument. Slate's Kriston Capps treats the Chili Queens as the dish's San Antonio source. The 1977 resolution naming chili the state dish, as CASI reprints it, ties the tradition to San Antonio more than 140 years back. National Geographic lays out rival origins: Aztec Mexico, washerwomen following the Mexican army, trail food of dried beef and chiles, Canary Islanders sent to San Antonio in the 1730s, and a legend about a Spanish nun. It concludes that no one knows for certain.

Hand-colored postcard: men in straw boaters sit at long cloth-covered tables lit by lanterns in an open plaza, a wagon with umbrellas at left and a large stone building with a tower behind.
"San Antonio, Texas. Chili Stands." Postcard published by Ebers & White, San Antonio, ca. 1907-1908. Ebers & White (publisher), DeGolyer Library, Southern Methodist University, via Wikimedia Commons, Public domain
Steel engraving of a broad dirt plaza with riders, mules and a group of men camped at left, a tall pole, and a domed church and bell tower behind low adobe buildings.
"Military Plaza, San Antonio, Texas," drawn by Arthur Schott, engraved by James D. Smillie, frontispiece to William H. Emory's Report on the United States and Mexican Boundary Survey (1857). Arthur Schott and James D. Smillie, New York Public Library, via Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

The camps

  1. A

    The San Antonio origin

    Chili con carne as Americans know it was born on the plazas of San Antonio, cooked by the Chili Queens.

    Slate's Kriston Capps (2015); CASI's history of chili; the 1977 Texas state dish resolution, which cites a San Antonio tradition.

  2. B

    Many roots

    The Chili Queens popularized the dish, but chiles and meat were cooked together long before and in many places. Its true origin is unknown.

    Rebecca Rupp, National Geographic (2015), who surveys the competing origin stories.

  3. C

    Pushed out by the health code

    Sanitation rules ended the stands. The city ordered them out in 1937 and closed them permanently in the early 1940s.

    San Antonio Light, 12 September 1937, via Barry Popik; Frank W. Jennings, Journal of San Antonio.

  4. D

    Squeezed out by competition

    Indoor restaurants complained to the health department, and the inspection rules that followed drove the women from the plazas by the 1930s.

    Jack Morgan, Texas Public Radio (2023).